Best Online Seafood Delivery List

Published on June 22, 2020

Last modified on June 7, 2023

This fresh fish Seafood Delivery list contains affiliate links and we may be compensated if you make a purchase.  All opinions are our own.

Written By Alison Chew     |    Dietitian Verified by Rebecca Housh, MS, RDN

 

 

Fresh Fish and Seafood Delivery

Not everyone can boast to have a body of water in their backyard, or the skills to explore the wildlife beneath it. I certainly can’t, but why let that prevent you from fresh fish just as good as your neighbor’s? MealFinds offers 20+ fresh fish services in our Seafood Delivery section for both novice eaters and expert connoisseurs. Don’t know where to begin? Aren’t sure about how to evaluate quality? Let us help you out!

First things first, in the following list of seafood delivery services we’ve researched you’re going to see the word sustainability a lot, but what does that mean for your fish? Here’s what Greensbury Market, first on the list, has to say.

Sustainable Seafood: “seafood that is caught or farmed using techniques that preserve the ocean’s health instead of harming it”

Some techniques of sustainable seafood practices, like the ones, not only used in Greensbury Market, but by all four of the other seafood delivery services broadly include handline, jig, long-line, and speargun fishing.

Instead of bottom trawling and dredging the ocean floor with nets as big as football fields, these non-invasive catching methods protect the environmental stability of their catches. It is just as important to maintain the quality of the habitat as it is to tend to the quality of the water.

No stability means no fresh fish!

 

 

Top 5 Online Seafood Delivery Companies

(with sustainably sourced fresh fish)

 

Wild Alaskan Company

Where does Wild Alaskan Company’s supply come from?

• Local fisheries in Alaska and the Pacific Northwest

 

How do I know my fresh fish is really fresh sustainably sourced?

Great question! Wild Alaskan Company seafood is certified by the following:

• The Alaskan State Constitution!

 

How long does it take my fresh fish to arrive?

The Wild Alaskan Company offers three delicious boxed plans for you to choose from that can be delivered every month or every other month. It’s up to you!

 

How much does the seafood delivery shipping cost?

• Standard shipping for a twelve-pack box of six-ounce fish selections is $9.95
• Standard shipping for a twenty-four pack box of six-ounce fish selections is free

 

Fulton Fish Market

Where does Fulton Fish Market’s supply come from?

• Across the globe! Fulton Fish Market is constantly searching and evaluating suppliers to offer the best quality of fresh fish in all their deliveries. Between one and two million pounds of seafood pour into their docks every midnight.  Best of all they are transparent about the country of origin and if the seafood is wild or farmed.

 

How do I know my fresh fish is really fresh and sustainably sourced?

Great question!

• Fulton Fish Market includes sustainable seafood logos on all of the sustainable seafood products they offer.  Look for the Monterey Bay Seafood Watch and/or NOAA Fishwatch logos on the approved items.

 

How long does it take for my fresh fish to arrive?

Up to you! All orders are delivered through FedEx. Whichever day works best for you, works best for them too.

 

How much does the seafood delivery shipping cost?

• After all coupons and savings are applied orders over $99 receive free standard shipping
• Shipping for orders under $99 is determined at checkout by FedEx standards

 

Save on your Fulton Fish Market Order Now!  See coupons >>

 

Vital Box

Where does Vital Box’s supply come from?

• Alaskan Pacific
• British Columbia Pacific
• Antarctic’s Ross Sea

 

How do I know my fresh fish is really fresh and sustainably sourced?

Great question! Vital Box seafood is certified by the following:

• B Corporation
• Marine Stewardship Council (MSC)
• Alaska’s Responsible Fisheries Management (RFM) Program

 

How long does it take for my fresh fish to arrive?

• Non-Perishable: 3 – 7 business days
• Frozen: 1 – 3 Day Express Ground Service or 2nd Day Air Service Monday – Wednesday
• Live Shellfish: only ships Monday – Thursday (orders must be placed before 5 p.m. PST the day before)
  • Sunday orders arrive Tuesday
  • Monday orders arrive Wednesday
  • Tuesday orders arrive Thursday
  • Wednesday orders arrive Friday
• Call 800-608-4825 to arrange for specific delivery time frames

 

How much does the seafood delivery shipping cost?

• Up to $49.99 = $6.95 shipping
• $50 – $98.99 = $12.95 shipping
• $99 and over = FREE shipping

 

Save on Vital Choice Seafood now!  See coupons >>

 

Sizzlefish

Where does the Sizzlefish supply come from?

• Alaskan Pacific, Pacific Coast, US
• Antarctica
• US Gulf Coast
• Mid-Atlantic, Northern Atlantic
• Lake Erie, US; Chesapeake Bay
• Some fish is farm-raised using environmentally friendly practices and no antibiotics

 

How do I know my fresh fish is really fresh and sustainably sourced?

Great question! Sizzlefish works with the following organizations to ensure sustainable and environmentally sound practices:

• Monterey Bay Aquarium Seafood Watch® program
• Alaska Seafood Marketing Institute

 

How long does it take for my fresh fish to arrive?

• 1-3 days to the East Coast via FedEx Ground with dry ice
• 2-3 days to the West Coast via FedEx Express with dry ice

 

How much does the seafood delivery shipping cost?

• Shipping is FREE on all orders!
• See coupons >>

 

Omaha Steaks

Where does Omaha Steaks supply come from?

• Across the globe! Omaha Steaks partners with World Port Seafood for responsibly caught, fresh fish delivered right to your door.

 

How do I know my fresh fish is really fresh and sustainably sourced?

Omaha Steaks does not list certifications on-site, but does say that fish is “Responsibly sourced from oceans around the globe” and some say “Sustainably certified” or “wild-caught”.

How much does the seafood delivery shipping cost and how long will it take to arrive?

• Get the best estimates on standard and express shipping options by zip code on the Omaha Steak website

 

Save on Omaha Steak Seafood now!  See coupons >>

Enjoy!

This post has been reviewed and approved by our dietitian Rebecca Housh, MS, RDN, LDN for nutritional accuracy.

Rebecca Housh is a registered dietitian based in Chicago, IL. She earned a Bachelor of Science in Human Physiology from Boston University and a Master of Science in Human Nutrition from the University of Illinois in Chicago. Rebecca is passionate about the idea of food as medicine in both preventative and therapeutic care. Her current professional interests lie in food security, food access, and nutrition for chronic disease.